Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Clever Pseudonym's avatar

I think it's hard to argue we're not at a similar spot as where Hannah Arendt begins her "Origins of Totalitarianism":

"The members of the elite did not object at all to paying a price, the destruction of civilization, for the fun of seeing how those who had been excluded unjustly in the past forced their way into it."

And I mention this because, while I am just as repulsed by our spoiled American Red Guard as anyone, these are still young people, and while that doesn't absolve them from blame, the ultimate responsibility lies with the adults who have failed them.

It would be so simple and easy to restore sanity and comity to American academia and discourse: if all the adult children who screeched obscenities at that judge had been immediately expelled, if those entitled infants who howled their rage into the face of Nick Christakis a few years ago at Yale had been immediately expelled etc etc, all these state-sanctioned tantrums would have been put to an end.

When we look back someday at how a peaceful prosperous country boiled over with hatred, when education was replaced by indoctrination, when a giant lie called "Critical Theory" became the official belief system of our elite class, an enormous amount of blame lies with our academic administrative class.

College trustees, presidents, boards, deans, profs, etc have failed their students, failed their country, and most especially have failed their beloved Liberalism by allowing it to be swallowed by intolerant Leftism without even a single peep of protest. They traded all their professed principles to maintain status, careers and money, and now all they can do is smile impotently from the sidelines, issue cringing apologies in the hopes that the mob burns them last, and count the days till they can escape on golden parachutes.

The abdication of adult authority is often how societies begin to unravel.

Expand full comment
Fran's avatar

No one will convince me that the Trump years weren't very instrumental in instituting a mindset that allowed for no difference of opinion. The students come across as extremely autocratic, rude, an offensive lot, and by no means liberal, quite the opposite. Clinton and the democrats in complicity with a highly biased media, as well as too many on the left, pushed the lie of Russia-gate, whose purpose was to remove an elected president,  yet no one has been held accountable for this crime. TV characters and movie stars were allowed to  advocate violence against Trump. Well, you have taught these kids anything goes. Yes people acted out before, but never has it been condoned the way it is now. Marches in the streets during a pandemic for Black Lives Matter, and infiltrated by too many who acted out in violent, destructive ways, and allowed to do so repeatedly with little to no consequences which went on for an extended period of time in democrat run cities.  Even violent acting out was not challenged, but condoned, or excused, or understood. Maybe the democrats can hide their adopted autocratic ways behind the facade of this BS. Bull shit that called a riot an insurrection, and allowed them to claim it was worse then our civil war where some 700 hundred thousand died, and where a country was so dangerously divided. What bothers me the most is Trump wanted to get along with Russia, but the democrats, the media wouldn't let him, oh but if they did the threat of a nuclear war would not be hanging over us now. One might think I am a registered republican, but no I was a registered democrat all my life, but now an independent with not a thought to ever voting for a democrat again.

Expand full comment
21 more comments...

No posts