Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Anthony S.'s avatar

Bill Maher's quote that the Dem party is now a Portlandia sketch would be apt if the people and situations in a Portlandia sketch were also defined by lack of principle, hypocrisy, lies, and off-the-charts levels of unreality within meaningful contexts.

- Comforting workers because they were traumatized by a Chik-Fil-A meal is Portlandia.

- Telling ICE to watch out for Denver moms is Portlandia.

- A NYT employee saying 2+2 doesn't always equal 4 is Portlandia.

But:

- Jen Rubin saying Republicans want to kill kids

- Joy Reid asserting that Musk and Putin own Trump

- Peter Baker saying you can't hold office if you're accused of a crime

- Gregg Gonsalves saying RFK Jr. thinks he knows better than scientists

That's not Portlandia. Portlandia is internally consistent in its worldview and weirdness.

This is something else.

This is challenging the shared human algorithms for determining reality.

This manufactures a subculture of irrationality within a universe of rational viewpoints.

A Portlandia sketch is cute and harmless and human. We're not living through Portlandia. We're watching progressives using our key institutions to indulge in motivated irrationality to arrive at conclusions they've already decided on.

Expand full comment
Mark Marshall's avatar

Robert Reich is what fascism looks like.

Expand full comment
32 more comments...

No posts